Rose Quartz
Retention

Women working together around a table

Sample audit.

Back to case studies

Sample audit

I signed up for 15% off. Ten minutes later, nothing.

The welcome email is the first proof a brand noticed the signup. When it doesn't come, the discount goes cold and so does the shopper.

At a glance

Case typeSample audit of the first visit and the signup.
NichePlanners and journaling.
The missJoined for 15% off the first order at 2:17 p.m. on October 4. No email by 2:25 p.m., in junk, promotions, or the primary inbox.
The fixA thank-you within 1 to 2 minutes, with the discount in it.

What I saw

I already owned one of their notebooks, so I came in as a returning fan. I opened the site as a first-time visitor and waited for a signup popup. None showed after 5 seconds, or at 10 when I moved the mouse off the screen.

The banners carried the season well. Fall refresh, new fall designs, a new fall bundle with a notebook, stickers, markers, and a bag organizer. Both buttons said Shop now, and Christmas products were already on the site when I clicked through. Bestsellers put weekly, daily, monthly, teacher, academic, A5, accessories, and custom on one screen, and I couldn't settle on one. Further down, a Compare our planners button named the choice. I'd keep that one.

Near the bottom, the page offered 15% off the first order for an email. I joined. The email didn't come.

What I'd change

Send the welcome fast. A thank-you within 1 to 2 minutes, with the promised 15% in it. A busy inbox won't hold the offer until later in the day.
Show the popup sooner. Within 2 to 3 seconds, or when the mouse leaves the screen. Ask for email or text. The cookie notice isn't that ask.
Keep the season in the button. Find your fall planner, or Shop your fall design. For the bundle: Find your fall bundle, or Personalize your fall bundle.
Cut bestsellers to 3 to 5. Three is what I'd use. A shopper who can't pick one, and is watching the price, can leave with nothing. Send custom photo art shoppers to their own segment instead of the first row.
Let the banners build the list. Each banner is already a segment. Keep an all-season list, then a tighter fall list for people who clicked the fall banners. Bundles, teachers, and custom photo gifts each get their own list, with birthdays as the moment for the gift list.

Offers I'd test

Gift bundle One bundle for the shopper and one for a friend, with 50% off the second, around a birthday, an event, or Black Friday.
Personalized gift Ask for photos and offer 20% off the next personalized gift around a birthday.
Teacher return A summer break contest with a free planner or writing accessory, then a percent off, or a free or half-off accessory, when teachers head back to school.
Halloween contest Two page styles, a cozy Halloween page and a spooky storytelling page. People vote, and more than one person can win.
VIP waitlist A new seasonal bundle opens a first-look list, so the next send has a reason that isn't a cold promotion.
Birthday loyalty $5 off the next purchase on their birthday.

What a founder can use

A seasonal banner can do two jobs: sell the season, and mark which season the shopper wants. Keep the button inside that season, and send the welcome email in the first minute or two with the discount in it.

About these numbers

This is a sample audit. Erin Condren didn't hire me, and these are changes I'd make, not changes they made. No revenue is attached. The times are from my own signup.

Schedule an audit