Rose Quartz
Retention

Women working together around a table

Sample audit.

Back to case studies

Sample audit

The wheel gave 20% off. The welcome email gave $15.

The wheel showed a code and then cleared it. The welcome email offered a different discount. Two offers at once, and I couldn't remember either.

At a glance

Case typeSample audit of the first visit and the welcome email.
NicheJournals, scrapbooking, and stationery accessories.
The miss20% off with a $70 minimum on the wheel, then a $15 discount in the welcome email.
The fixEmail the wheel code, or replace the wheel with a short quiz.

What I saw

A spin wheel popped as soon as I hovered. I put in an email and won 20% off with a $70 minimum. The code sat on screen, then cleared itself. I wanted it in an email, because I wasn't going to remember it.

The photo already had the vintage journaling personality. The banner words were hard to read over it, and the button said Shop now, which doesn't carry that personality. A bestseller line said the product had sparked countless creative journeys, then grab it before it's gone. The line didn't name the product, so I couldn't tell what it was selling. Grab yours before it's gone is worth keeping once it names the thing.

They sell journals and notebooks as well as stamps, sticker sheets, paper packs, washi, and bundles. A vintage patterns paper pack showed reviews with a purchase count and star rating, which I liked. But about 200 products sat in one pile, filtered only by product type and availability. I'm not going through nine pages to find the thing I came to make.

The welcome email

Welcome. Let's get creative.

Enjoy an exclusive welcome bonus on your first order.

Welcome 315. Perfect for bundles.

The email led with a $15 discount. By then I'd forgotten the wheel code, and I couldn't tell whether the two could be used together. I liked the bundle line. The welcome talked about a community, then showed products, and the same jumble as the shop.

What I'd change

Email the wheel code. Send it the moment the screen clears it.
Make the banner readable. A light overlay behind the words, something like white at about 30% transparency. Use a button line that stays inside the vintage journaling photo.
Break up the 200 products. Add categories or a vibe filter, so floral, postage stamps, mini book paper, vintage charm paper and sticker packs, washi, and botanical wooden stamps aren't one block. A person making a nature page and a person looking for stamps are different shoppers.
Ask for a first name. The welcome said hey there. Capture a name on signup so the email can use it.
Trade the wheel for a quiz. Three to five questions on the homepage, then the coupon, then the products that match the answers.
Use the first choice later. If they chose floral, show floral stamps. If they bought stamps, show a small project that uses them, in sends from October through spring.

What a founder can use

One offer, delivered where the shopper can find it again. A short quiz asks what someone is making before the coupon, and the first email can use their name and show the products that match.

About these numbers

This is a sample audit. PaperWrld didn't hire me, and these are changes I'd make, not changes they made. No revenue is attached. The discounts and product count are what the site and welcome email showed me.

Schedule an audit